AvMed data breach case opens door for ID theft claims

Share this article:

A recent federal appeals court ruling may narrow the burden for plaintiffs to prove that they are victims of identity theft as result of a data breach.

Plaintiffs Juana Curry and William Moore alleged in a class-action lawsuit filed in 2010 that they sustained ID theft following an incident the year prior in which two unencrypted laptops, containing the personal information of 1.2 million customers, were stolen from Florida health insurer AvMed. (The victim total initially was much lower, but later revised by the company).

In August 2011, a U.S. District Court judge dismissed the case after concluding that the plaintiffs were unable to represent "injury" as a result of the laptop thefts.

But earlier this month, the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, in a 2-1 decision (PDF), ruled that the plaintiffs were "explicitly" able to prove a link between the breach and ID theft they incurred.

The plaintiffs contended that roughly a year after the incident, bank and brokerage accounts were opened in their names, resulting in unauthorized charges and transactions. They were forced to spend money to place fraud alerts and purchase identity theft protection services, among other costs.

Page 1 of 2
Share this article:

Sign up to our newsletters

More in News

Firefox 32 feature could cut undetected malware downloads 'in half'

Mozilla plans to introduce a feature in Firefox 32 that, based on preliminary testing, could cut the amount of undetected malware downloads in half.

EFF asks court to find NSA internet spying a violation of Fourth Amendment

EFF asks court to find NSA internet spying ...

Complete with a colorful graphic, the EFF showed a federal court how the NSA essentially runs a digital dragnet that can pick up innocent Americans.

Study: Asian Android users at higher risk of malware exposure

Cheetah Mobile's new study showed that Asian Android users have a two to three times greater risk of downloading malware onto their devices.